Hyatt Center at 71 S. Wacker
Exterior Glass a Towering Issue for Pritzker Skyscraper
by Jeffrey Steele
Penny Pritzker stood atop a 50-story Loop high-rise on a
sunny but bitterly cold late autumn afternoon 18 months ago
for a simple reason.
It was all about glass.
Tom Scheckelhoff, senior vice president and project manager
of the Chicago architecture firm A. Epstein & Sons, said
Pritzker was helping determine the exterior glass that would
be used in Hyatt Center at 71 South Wacker, the Loop skyscraper
her family's company would soon be building.
"Everyone wanted as light a glass as possible,"
said Michael Damore, senior executive vice president and director
of architecture and planning with A. Epstein & Sons, the
architect of record on the Hyatt Center project. "Reflective
buildings are not as effective aesthetically. In addition,
they really give a darker view and at night become a mirror
from the inside. We wanted to avoid that."
|
Fortunately, advancements in glass technology allowed alternatives
to be considered.
"Modern glass has improved a lot in the last few years,
and they use coatings on the glass and gas between glass layers
to ensure today's glass approaches the energy efficiency of
tinted or reflective glass a few years ago," Scheckelhoff
said. "That allows us to use more glass, larger pieces
and more transparent glass than just a few years ago."
From a list of 50 possible glass alternatives, the design
team narrowed the search to about a dozen, then to a short
list of three. A light box - a 3-ft. cube designers slid different
glass panes into - was constructed to compare options. The
objective of the box was to demonstrate how the glass would
look on the side of the building.
"You can move it around and pick up the sunlight,"
Scheckelhoff said. "That was where the decision was eventually
made."
It was at this point that the Pritzker family made a decision
on a brutally cold day in late 2002. "Imagine Penny Pritzker
standing up on a roof of a 50-story building a block away
from 71 South Wacker on Nov. 18, 2002," making a determination
as to which glass should be used, Scheckelhoff said. "It
was almost a comedic scene."
Owatonna, Minn.-based Viracon was chosen as the glass supplier.
Has 1.75 Million Sq. Ft.
Rising on a half block site bordered by Wacker Drive, Franklin
and Monroe streets and an alley one-half block north of Monroe,
the 1.75-million-sq.-ft. building will soar 49 stories.
Through the sixth floor, Hyatt Center's floor plates measure
50,000 sq. ft., with each of the floors above six encompassing
about 34,000 sq. ft.
A look at a few numbers demonstrates the sheer scope of the
building project, said Jeff Riemer, executive vice president
of Bovis Lend Lease, the construction manager in Chicago.
Covering 1.5 acres, Hyatt Center will use 12,000 tons of structural
steel and feature about 65,000 cu. yds. of concrete. The exterior
of the building will be made up of about 7,000 unitized curtain
wall panels measuring 5 ft. wide by one story - or 14 ft.,
2 in. - tall.
Excavation began in July 2002, with construction beginning
four months later. First occupancies of the structure are
slated for late this year.
The site had been home to three buildings. One was the 13-story
Hart Shaffner & Marx manufacturing plant, which covered
the east half of the site. Two other buildings stood on the
northwest and southwest corners of the parcel, the latter
serving as the home of the Kent College of Law.
The buildings all fell to the wrecking ball in the 1980s,
and the parcel has been used as a parking lot in recent years.
Dealing with Bell Caissons
Excavation work extended down to the second basement level
of the previous buildings. "There was a sizable excavation
because a foundation for the previous building was still in
the ground," said Jim Swanson, principal of Chicago's
Halvorson Kaye Structural Engineers.
"What we found down there were wood piles in about half
the site, and bell caissons in the other half."
The wood piles weren't difficult to remove and if they interfered
with the new building's caissons, they were simply pulled
out of the ground.
But the bell caissons proved more problematic.
Swanson said a bell caisson is created by drilling a hole
in the ground and carving out a conical shape at the bottom
of the shaft to create a subterranean space larger at the
bottom than the top.
The bell caissons were enough of an obstruction that in some
instances, two new caissons had to be added to straddle the
old bell caissons, with a transfer beam bridging the top.
No transfer beams were needed above ground because the columns
extend all the way from the building's roof to its foundation,
Swanson said.
"All the lateral loads are resisted by the concrete core
walls in the center of the building," he added. "The
profile of those core walls really mimics the perimeter of
the building. It's a football-shaped building, and it comes
to a bit of a point at each end.
The distance between the perimeter columns and the core is
a consistent dimension.
That allowed all the steel beams to be of the same length
- an issue of economy."
The core is about 50 ft. at the center, and the building height
is about 700 ft., Swanson said. The resultant aspect ratio
of the height to the core is a fairly narrow 14 to 1, which
compelled designers to provide the building with a stiff core
designed to resist lateral loads.
"[That] really means concrete becomes the best solution,"
he added. "The core is concrete and the structure outside
the core structural steel.
"It's really classified as a composite building."
Materials Issues
That composite nature allows the builders to take advantage
of the best characteristics of each material. Concrete is
not only stiffer and therefore a better material for the core,
but is also heavier, which helps the building resist overturning
in heavy winds, Swanson said.
The steel, on the other hand, allows the gravity-supported
system to produce a much lighter-weight structure. Lightweight
concrete slab on metal deck is supported by the steel beams
emerging from the core. The building will feature unobstructed
clear spans of 42 ft., meaning steel beams were the only conceivable
choice.
Both the concrete and steel systems support the gravity loads
from the floors. But due to the different properties of the
two elements, the building features differential shortening
between the stiff concrete at the core and the lighter steel
columns at the perimeter, Swanson added. To compensate, the
floor framing is being installed out of plumb, because some
settling will occur.
"One of the trickier things the contractor had to do
was ensure as the building is erected, it's not being erected
flat like you'd normally want, but erected with pitched floors,"
he said. "And that pitch varied from floor to floor."
'Doable but Fast' Schedule
Riemer called the schedule "doable but fast" and
said the team from the beginning "mobilized and planned"
for that tight timetable.
"When we first planned how to do the structural erection,
we worked out that the project could be done with one crane,
and still make the schedule," Riemer added.
"But we had this gnawing worry of what happens if we
have a severe winter or high winds.
"So we made the decision we would add another crane,
to add to our capacity to erect steel. And that was a good
decision. That helped us maintain schedule."
The delivery and staging of materials benefited from the same
careful planning. Most of the materials were manufactured
and stored at factories producing them until they were needed
onsite.
Steel, for example, was manufactured in Wolcott, Ind., about
a two-hour drive from Chicago. When needed, the steel would
be loaded on trucks and arrive onsite two hours later. Curtain
walls were manufactured in Connecticut and inventoried there
until needed. They were brought to the site on trucks and
stored on the floors where they would be used.
Similarly, mechanical equipment was stored at the manufacturing
facilities producing it until contractors were ready to install
the machinery. "We had a lot of cooperation from our
suppliers," Riemer said. "We've had a great team,
and that's been a key factor in the success we've been able
to achieve."
|